General Topics to Consider:
Potential questions to respond to (and potentially useful sources):
2. Develop a comparison involving three (3) of the characters in Shelley's novel in terms of their relationship to Nature. How do their views of or interaction with Nature influence what these characters do in the novel and what eventually happens to them? Explain by using very specific references to the novel, quoting specific passages to support your claims. (Bate, Mellor, Poovey)
3. The word "doppelgänger" was used repeatedly in our
discussion. Explain the degree to which both Clerval and
the Creature can be seen as doppelgängers for
Victor, discussing such issues as relationship to Nature,
relationship to Women, and view of Self in your
discussion. Be sure to include quotes from Victor that
describe his view of the similarities between himself and each
of the other two figures. (Levine,
Gilbert & Gubar, Mellor) (Helpful Link
)
4. Describe the criminal justice system(s) presented in
this novel, using the three examples of William's murder,
Clerval's murder, and Elizabeth's murder, as well as the
official responses to these acts, in your discussion. Is
it a fair system? Do all crimes get investigated in the same
way? Do some people receive preferential treatment? If so,
who? What characteristics determine the treatment the different
suspects receive? Incorporate your responses to these
questions into a smooth discussion that includes quotes
describing each of these situations. (Sayres
, Wake
, Vincent
)
6. Explain the significance of the dream Victor has the
night that he succeeds in bringing life to his creation. Explain
the symbolism of the images involved in terms of the
themes presented in the work as a whole. You should
incorporate discussion of Victor's view of and relationship to
Family, Women, and Sexuality in your discussion, using quotes
from other parts of the novel to support your discussion. (Poovey
, Cottom
,Winnett
)
(Helpful Link
)
9. Compare the relationships between Victor and his father and that between Victor and his creature. What are the similarities and differences? You may wish to consider Victor's question to Clerval--"How could you suppose that my first thoughts would not fly towards those dear, dear friends whom I love, and who are so deserving of my love?" (40)--in light of the fact that his first thoughts do not "fly" there. (Lipking, Levine, Moers, Gilbert & Gubar)
10. What are the similarities and differences involved
in the comparison between the relationships involving Victor
& Elizabeth and the Creature & his potential female
mate? How do Victor and the Creature view their "partners"
and their future "married" lives? Look specifically at the
discussion between Victor and the Creature at the end of the
second section. (Mellor, Winnett
)
11. Why does the Creature frame Justine for the murder of
William? What does this say about the way he has learned to view
women? What does this say about the criminal justice
system and society in general in the novel? (Wake
, Mellor)
12. What is the function of solitude in this novel? Look specifically at Victor and the Creature. Do they have the same view of solitude? Does it have the same effect on them? Explain. (Mellor, Poovey, Lipking)